DEFENDING ERNESTO VALVERDE: AN UNDERSTANDING OF HIS PERFORMANCE AND CHALLENGES
Ernesto Valverde, the former manager of FC Barcelona, has faced unprecedented levels of criticism and abuse from the team's fanbase. His tenure has been marred by expectations of constant success and adherence to traditional playing styles, yet Valverde's defensive approach and reliance on core players have been met with mistrust and skepticism by many fans. This article aims to provide a contextual analysis of the criticisms levied against Valverde and to present a nuanced view of his contributions to the club.
A Critical Look at Valverde's Critics
The narrative surrounding Valverde is often shaped by the successes and failures of FC Barcelona, with recent outcomes serving as benchmarks for managerial performance. This has created an environment where any setback, particularly in the UEFA Champions League, is attributed to Valverde's failures. However, it is important to consider the broader context of Valverde's tenure and the challenges he faced from the outset.
The Anti-Cruyff Game Plan
The criticism regarding Valverde's game plan is rooted in the perception that his defensive approach is anti-Cruyffian, despite the shift away from Guardiola's style long before Valverde's appointment. It is noteworthy that the team's playing style has evolved over the years, influenced by the changes in player dynamics and the changing landscape of the sport.
Midfield Crisis
Barcelona's midfield, once considered one of the best in the world, has deteriorated significantly. The departure of Iniesta and the decline of Busquets have necessitated a shift towards a more defensive flow. Valverde's response was not to abandon the team's principles but to adapt the style in line with the available talent. The team's performance in 2017/18, with a defensive core of Busquets, Rakitic, Paulinho, and Iniesta, demonstrates the effectiveness of this defensive framework. The team's ability to maintain clean sheets and build offensive attacks around Messi showcases Valverde's tactical acumen.
Reliance on Core Players
Another criticism levelled at Valverde is the team's reliance on core players such as MATS, Sergi Roberto, Busquets, Suarez, and Messi. It is a fact that any manager with a core of these players would be expected to play them consistently. However, the argument that Valverde's approach to playing these players is indicative of a lack of faith in the squad or a reluctance to develop new talent is unfounded. Valverde has demonstrated flexibility in adapting to the available talent and ensuring that the team remains competitive.
Adapting to New Talent
The arrival of Frenkie de Jong and Ansu Fati has been a significant development, but it is important to acknowledge the evolution of the squad over time. The integration of new players and the management of a highly talented core have been critical elements of Valverde's tenure. The team's success in the 2017/18 season, despite a decrease in goalscoring efficiency, demonstrates Valverde's ability to manage the team effectively.
Conclusion
No manager who has lost 12 games across all competitions over two seasons should be subjected to the abuse and criticism currently faced by Valverde. The lack of context and historical perspective is leading many to believe that FC Barcelona is experiencing a downturn. It is not out of selfishness or a perverse desire to place themselves above the team that senior players have supported Valverde, but rather a recognition of his efforts to keep the team afloat during a transitional period.
Valverde deserves respect and trust for all he has done for FC Barcelona since taking over in 2017. His contributions to the team extend beyond the results on the pitch and include the morale and stability he has provided to the squad. Ernesto Valverde is a coach aiming to do his best for his players and his club, and it's time for Cules to see him for who he is.