What Would Ned Have Done if Jon Had Blonde Hair: Implications for Targaryen Identity

Introduction

The iconic character of Jon Snow in George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series has often been a subject of intense interest and debate. Ned Stark's decision on how to integrate Jon into the Targaryen lineage would have been pivotal. If Jon had blonde hair, his integration would present different challenges and potential solutions, explored in this article.

Integrating Jon into Targaryen Lineage

The notion of Jon being a Targaryen would have been preposterous to most characters in the fictional world of Westeros. Specifically, considering Jon's hair color as a wild card factor, the challenge would have been to integrate him without arousing suspicion.

One potential solution would be raising him on Driftmark or Claw Isle. Both of these locations are held by House Velaryon and House Celtigar, sworn to Targaryen once, and both were not retributed for their allegiance during Robert's rebellion. These locations would make it easier to pass Jon off as a Stark water stag, particularly since Lord Monford Velaryon already had a son named Aurane. Jon and Aurane could be raised as brothers.

The Risk of Detection

The only issue with this solution would be if Robert Baratheon decided to visit Driftmark or Claw Isle. Any resemblance between Jon and Lyanna or Rhaegar Targaryen could lead to suspicion, potentially jeopardizing his safety and the integrity of the ruse.

Alternative Solutions

Another strategy would be to send Jon to one of the Free Cities, such as Braavos or Pentos, where Valyrian blood is prevalent. If Jon had blonde Valyrian hair, he would blend in well, making it easier to maintain the ruse of his Targaryen heritage. However, this would require continuous monitoring from Ned to ensure Jon's safety and maintain secrecy.

The Dilemma of Keeping Jon at Winterfell

Given the risks of Jon's presence at Winterfell, especially with Robert Baratheon, another solution would be to find a method for him to blend in. One such method would be to acquire hair dye from Tyrosh. Hair dye would need to be natural in appearance and less conspicuous. If Ned could obtain such dye, Jon could pass as a Stark and avoid drawing attention.

Conclusion

In conclusion, if Jon had blonde hair, the challenge would be significant, requiring careful planning and execution to ensure his safety and integrate him into Targaryen history without arousing suspicion. Potential solutions include raising him on Driftmark or Claw Isle, sending him to the Free Cities, or utilizing hair dye. Each option would present its own set of challenges and opportunities, ultimately shaping his journey in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire.