Why Do Some Blues Purists Frown Upon Contemporary Guitar Players?

Blues purists often have specific criteria for what constitutes 'true' blues. This article explores the reasons why some purists view contemporary guitar players like Gary Moore and Joe Bonamassa in a critical light. We will delve into the issues of commercialization, style and technique, authenticity, instrument and production choices, and cultural context. Additionally, we will discuss how these perspectives lead to a divide between purists and modern musicians, and why many fans appreciate the evolution of the blues.

Commercialization

Blues purists frequently express concerns about the commercialization of the blues. They believe that modern musicians prioritize mass appeal over the genre's traditional roots and emotional depth. This attitude is rooted in a desire to preserve the authenticity of the blues, which many purists see as intrinsically tied to its historical and cultural significance.

Style and Technique

Contemporary blues players often incorporate elements from other genres such as rock, jazz, and even pop. This blurring of boundaries can be seen as a departure from the classic 12-bar structure and the raw, emotive playing style that purists cherish. For example, Gary Moore and Joe Bonamassa are known for their virtuosic playing, which some purists argue strays from the traditional blues aesthetic.

Authenticity

Blues purists often place a heavy emphasis on personal experience and storytelling in the genre. They believe that true blues must be rooted in the life experiences and cultural backgrounds of the artists who perform it. This perspective can lead purists to question the authenticity of contemporary players who may not have shared the same experiences that shaped the original blues tradition.

Instrument and Production Choices

The use of modern technology and polished production techniques can give contemporary blues a different feel. Many purists prefer the raw, unrefined sound of classic blues recordings, which they see as a more genuine representation of the genre. This preference for a more natural, organic sound can be seen as a reaction against the digital age, where many modern recordings have a more processed and slick production.

Cultural Context

The blues originated from specific cultural and historical contexts, particularly within African American communities. Some purists may feel that modern players who do not share this background cannot fully capture the essence of the genre. This cultural context is seen as an essential element of authenticity in the blues, and any deviation from it can be viewed as a lose of this cultural core.

Evolution of the Blues

While these perspectives can create a divide between purists and contemporary musicians, many fans appreciate the evolution of the blues. Modern artists like Gary Moore and Joe Bonamassa can bring new energy and perspectives to the genre while still honoring its roots. This evolution can be seen as a natural progression, where the blues continues to adapt and remain relevant to contemporary audiences.

Both Gary Moore and Joe Bonamassa are indeed excellent guitar players, and their skills are most evident in their rock-pop oriented work. However, it's important to recognize that their contributions should not be dismissed purely on the grounds of genre purity. Their unique styles add new dimensions to the blues, making it more accessible and exciting for a modern audience.

Freddie King's Authenticity

Freddie King, a legendary blues guitarist, is often cited as an example of true blues authenticity. In a video clip, he demonstrates an unmatched level of raw emotion and personal experience in his playing. This authenticity, though difficult to describe in words, is what many purists believe sets true blues apart from other styles.

In conclusion, the divide between blues purists and contemporary players is complex and multifaceted. It reflects a deep appreciation for the genre's historical and cultural significance, as well as a commitment to preserving its authenticity. However, the blues is a living, evolving art form, and modern artists continue to push its boundaries while honoring its rich heritage.